Political regimes of the world: a two-axis typology

Constitutional form and nature of power: the two-axis typology applied to the 196 countries, with each country's V-Dem category.

A two-axis typology

The atlas classifies each country on two axes: the constitutional form (presidential, semi-presidential, parliamentary, monarchical, directorial, assembly…), read in the constitution in force or, where no constitution is applied (Afghanistan, Eritrea, transitional regimes), in the charter or the actual institutions given in the country profile; and the nature of power, that is, who actually governs (pluralist institutions, one-party state, junta or transitional authority, theocracy, ruling monarch). Federalism is a separate attribute.

Neither axis measures democratic quality. That comes from two independent sources displayed next to each country: the Regimes of the World classification of V-Dem and the Freedom House status. The definitions come from the literature (Duverger, Shugart and Carey, Elgie, Cheibub, Lührmann et al.; see the references at the bottom of the page).

Constitutional forms at a glance

Two questions are enough to place a form: how is the head of state chosen, and to whom is the government accountable?

Form Head of state Government accountable to Examples
Presidential President elected (by direct vote, or as head of list in the legislative elections) for a fixed term, head of the executive The president alone, not parliament United States, Brazil, Mexico, Nigeria, Indonesia
Semi-presidential (Elgie) President elected by universal suffrage for a fixed term Parliament (premier-presidential) or parliament and the president (president-parliamentary) France, Poland, Portugal, Ireland (premier-presidential); Russia, Austria, Peru (president-parliamentary)
Parliamentary Not elected by universal suffrage (parliament or college), or collegial Parliament Germany, Italy, India, Israel, Greece
Parliamentary with an executive president Chosen by parliament, combines the offices of head of state and head of the executive Parliament (motion of no confidence) or, once elected, no one (Suriname, Micronesia) South Africa, Botswana
Parliamentary monarchy Hereditary monarch, essentially ceremonial Parliament United Kingdom, Canada, Japan, Sweden, Spain
Executive monarchy Monarch who appoints and dismisses the government and sets its direction The monarch Morocco, Jordan, Bahrain, Kuwait
Absolute monarchy Monarch who concentrates executive and legislative powers The monarch Saudi Arabia, Oman, Brunei, Eswatini
Directorial Collegial executive elected by parliament for a fixed term No one: the college cannot be dismissed Switzerland
Assembly system Elected by the assembly, the “supreme organ of state power” The assembly (the nature of power is given by axis 2) China, Vietnam, Laos, Cuba, North Korea
50
Presidential system
47
Semi-presidential system
31
Parliamentary system
9
Parliamentary system with an executive president
1
Directorial system
5
Assembly system (unity of state power)
30
Parliamentary monarchy
6
Executive (semi-constitutional) monarchy
7
Absolute monarchy
8
Transitional charter
2
No constitution in force

Presidential system

50 countries

President elected (by direct vote, or as head of list in the legislative elections) for a fixed term, head of the executive; the government is not collectively accountable to parliament (Shugart and Carey 1992). A prime minister may exist, but he or she answers to the president alone.

AngolaElectoral autocracy ArgentinaElectoral democracy BeninElectoral autocracy BoliviaElectoral democracy BrazilElectoral democracy BurundiElectoral autocracy ChileLiberal democracy ColombiaElectoral democracy ComorosElectoral autocracy Costa RicaLiberal democracy Côte d'IvoireElectoral autocracy CyprusLiberal democracy DjiboutiElectoral autocracy Dominican RepublicElectoral democracy EcuadorElectoral democracy El SalvadorElectoral autocracy Equatorial GuineaElectoral autocracy Gabonmilitary or transitional regime · Electoral autocracy GambiaElectoral democracy GhanaElectoral democracy GuatemalaElectoral democracy Guineamilitary or transitional regime · Closed autocracy HondurasElectoral democracy IndonesiaElectoral autocracy Irantheocracy · Electoral autocracy KenyaElectoral democracy KyrgyzstanElectoral autocracy LiberiaElectoral democracy MalawiElectoral democracy Malimilitary or transitional regime · Closed autocracy MexicoElectoral autocracy NicaraguaElectoral autocracy NigeriaElectoral democracy Palaunot covered by V-Dem PanamaElectoral democracy ParaguayElectoral democracy PhilippinesElectoral autocracy SeychellesLiberal democracy Sierra LeoneElectoral autocracy South KoreaLiberal democracy South Sudanmilitary or transitional regime · Closed autocracy TajikistanElectoral autocracy TürkiyeElectoral autocracy TurkmenistanElectoral autocracy UgandaElectoral autocracy United StatesElectoral democracy UruguayLiberal democracy VenezuelaElectoral autocracy ZambiaElectoral autocracy ZimbabweElectoral autocracy

Semi-presidential system

47 countries

Elgie's definition: a president elected by universal suffrage for a fixed term coexists with a prime minister and a government collectively accountable to parliament. The definition is formal: it does not depend on the president's actual powers (Ireland and Austria fall under it).

Premier-presidential (27)

The government is accountable to parliament alone; the president cannot dismiss it (Shugart and Carey 1992).

President-parliamentary (20)

The government is accountable both to parliament and to the president, who can dismiss it (Shugart and Carey 1992).

Parliamentary system

31 countries

The head of government emerges from parliament and is accountable to it; the head of state is not elected by universal suffrage (elected by parliament or a college) or is collegial (Bosnia & Herzegovina).

Parliamentary system with an executive president

9 countries

The president is chosen by parliament (or as leader of the majority) and combines the functions of head of state and head of the executive. Sub-type “responsable”: he or she can be removed by a motion of no confidence (South Africa, Botswana). Sub-type “independant_assemblee”: once elected, he or she is no longer accountable to the assembly (Suriname, Micronesia, Myanmar; “assembly-independent” in Shugart and Carey).

Accountable to parliament (6)

Assembly-independent (3)

Directorial system

1 country

Collegial executive elected by parliament for a fixed term, not subject to dismissal (Switzerland).

Assembly system (unity of state power)

5 countries

The constitution makes the assembly the “supreme organ of state power”; it elects the head of state and the government, which report to it. This is the constitutional form of one-party states (China art. 57, Vietnam, Laos, Cuba, North Korea); the nature of power is given by axis 2.

Parliamentary monarchy

30 countries

Monarch as head of state; the government emerges from parliament and is accountable to it. The monarch may retain prerogatives (Bhutan, Tonga, Thailand) without leading the government.

Executive (semi-constitutional) monarchy

6 countries

A constitution and an elected parliament exist, but the monarch appoints and dismisses the government, which is accountable to him, and sets the broad direction (Anckar; Corbett, Veenendaal and Ugyel). Morocco, Jordan, Bahrain, Kuwait (Assembly dissolved and articles of the constitution suspended by the emir on 10 May 2024).

Absolute monarchy

7 countries

The monarch concentrates executive and legislative powers; the fundamental texts are granted and the assemblies are consultative or appointed.

Transitional charter

8 countries

The constitution is suspended or subordinated to a transitional charter or declaration (Burkina Faso, Niger, Sudan, Syria, Libya…). The formal constitution remains cited in the country profile.

No constitution in force

2 countries

No constitution is applied: text repealed or suspended without replacement (Afghanistan since 2021) or never implemented (Eritrea, constitution of 1997).

Axis 2: the nature of power

Form tells how the constitution organises power; nature tells who actually governs. In 161 countries, power proceeds from the institutions provided for by the constitution (value “Power derived from constitutional institutions”), which says nothing about democratic quality: quality comes from V-Dem and Freedom House, displayed next to each country. The other countries are classified below.

6
One-party state
16
Military or transitional regime
3
Theocracy
10
Ruling monarchy

One-party state

6 countries

The constitution or practice reserves power to one party, whose leadership is the real seat of decision-making (China, Vietnam, Laos, Cuba, North Korea, Eritrea).

Military or transitional regime

16 countries

Power is exercised outside the ordinary constitutional framework: a junta that came to power in a coup, a transitional authority without a renewed electoral mandate, or a constitution that gives the army an autonomous governing role (Myanmar, constitution of 2008: a quarter of the seats and the ministries of Defence, Home Affairs and Border Affairs). The nature is maintained, with a dated note, when the head of the junta was elected in a vote organised by the junta itself (Gabon 2025, Guinea 2025-2026, Myanmar 2026).

Theocracy

3 countries

Supreme authority is religious and takes precedence over elected bodies: the Supreme Leader in Iran (constitution arts. 5, 57 and 110), the Commander of the Faithful in Afghanistan.

Ruling monarchy

10 countries

The monarch (or the crown prince by delegation) effectively governs: absolute monarchies and executive monarchies.

Federalism

25 countries

Attribute separate from the type: true if the constitution divides sovereignty between the central state and federated entities endowed with guaranteed powers of their own (regime.federal).

References

The definitions of the two axes and the correspondence table are in data/reference/regime-types.json.

  • Duverger, Maurice (1980). “A New Political System Model: Semi-Presidential Government”. European Journal of Political Research 8(2).
  • Shugart, Matthew S. and Carey, John M. (1992). Presidents and Assemblies. Cambridge University Press.
  • Elgie, Robert (2011). Semi-Presidentialism: Sub-Types and Democratic Performance. Oxford University Press.
  • Cheibub, José A., Gandhi, Jennifer and Vreeland, James R. (2010). “Democracy and Dictatorship Revisited”. Public Choice 143.
  • Geddes, Barbara, Wright, Joseph and Frantz, Erica (2014). “Autocratic Breakdown and Regime Transitions: A New Data Set”. Perspectives on Politics 12(2).
  • Anckar, Carsten (Åbo Akademi University) (2021). “Constitutional monarchies and semi-constitutional monarchies: a global historical study”. Contemporary Politics.
  • Corbett, Jack, Veenendaal, Wouter and Ugyel, Lhawang (2017). “Why monarchy persists in small states”. Democratization 24(4).
  • Lührmann, Anna, Tannenberg, Marcus and Lindberg, Staffan I. (2018). “Regimes of the World (RoW)”. Politics and Governance 6(1).
  • Comparative Constitutions Project, Constitute (constituteproject.org): constitutional texts in force.

Reference list for semi-presidentialism: Robert Elgie, “List of president-parliamentary and premier-presidential countries with dates” (as of 28 June 2018).

What the classification does not say

The constitutional form says nothing about how democracy actually works. Russia is a semi-presidential republic in Elgie's sense (an elected president and a government accountable to the Duma), Hungary a parliamentary republic; both countries are classed as electoral autocracy by V-Dem (Regimes of the World). In a one-party state, a junta or a theocracy, the constitution does not say who governs: that is the role of the “nature of power” axis.

On the maps, colour indicates the political family of the effective holder of power and pattern the democratic quality (V-Dem category). A country classed as an “electoral autocracy” keeps the colour of its leader but receives a pattern that distinguishes it from a neighbouring liberal democracy.

→ Detailed method on regimes and political families · → Presidential, parliamentary, semi-presidential (in French) · → V-Dem and Freedom House cross-referenced (in French)